Synthesis, and characterization of metallic glassy Cu–Zr–Ni powders decorated with big cube Zr2Ni nanoparticles for potential antibiofilm coating applications

Biofilms, are significant component that contributes to the development of chronic infections, especially when medical devices are involved. This issue offers a huge challenge for the medical community since standard antibiotics are only capable of eradicating biofilms to a very limited degree. The prevention of biofilm formation have led to the development of a variety of coating methods and new materials. These methods are intended to coat surfaces in such a way as to inhibit the formation of biofilm. Metallic glassy alloys, in particular, alloys that include copper and titanium metals have gained popularity as desirable antibacterial coating. Meanwhile, there has been a rise in the use of the cold spray coating technique due to the fact that it is a proper approach for processing temperature-sensitive materials. The present study was carried out in part with the intention of developing a new antibiofilm metallic glassy consisting of ternary Cu–Zr–Ni using mechanical alloying technique. The spherical powders that comprised the end-product were utilized as feedstock materials for cold spray coatings to stainless steel surfaces at low temperature. When compared to stainless steel, substrates coated with metallic glassy were able to significantly reduce the formation of biofilm by at least one log.

The capacity of any society throughout human history to design and instigate the introduction of novel materials that meet their specific requirements has resulted in the improvement of their performance and ranking in the globalized economy 1 . It is always attributed to man's ability to develop materials and manufacturing equipment and devises used for materials fabrication and characterization, as measured by progress made in health, education, industry, economics, culture, and other areas, from one country or region to another, and this is true regardless of the country or region 2 . Materials scientists have devoted the considerable time over the 60 years focusing their attention on one primary concern: the pursuit for novel and cutting-edge materials. Recent research has concentrated on enhancing the qualities and performance of already existing materials, as well as synthesizing and inventing whole new types of materials.
The incorporation of alloying elements, the modification of the material's microstructure, and the application of thermal, mechanical, or thermo-mechanical processing techniques have led to significant enhancements in the mechanical, chemical, and physical properties of a variety of different materials. In addition, hitherto unheardof compounds have been successfully synthesized at this point. These persistent efforts have led to the birth of new families of innovative materials that are collectively referred to as advanced materials 2 . Nanocrystalline, nanoparticles, nanotubes, quantum dots, zero dimensional, amorphous metallic glasses, and high entropy alloys are just some of the examples of advanced materials that were introduced to the worldwide since the middle of the past century 1 . When it comes to the fabrication and developing of new alloys with superior characteristics, it is often a question of increasing the deviation from equilibrium, in either the final product or at an intermediate stage of its production. As a result of the implementation of new preparation techniques for having a significant deviation from equilibrium, an entirely new class of metastable alloys called metallic glasses was discovered 3 . www.nature.com/scientificreports/ the features that may be effectively improved by surface treatments include wear, oxidation, and corrosion resistance, friction coefficients, bio-inertness, electrical properties, and thermal insulation, to name a few examples 1 . Improvements in surface qualities may be produced by the use of metallurgical, mechanical, or chemical techniques. As a well-known process, coating is simply defined as a single or multilayered materials deposited artificially on the surface of a bulk object (substrate) made of another material. Hence, coating is used to obtain some required technical or decorative properties in part, as well as to protect the material from expected chemical and physical interactions with its surrounding environment 23 . For depositing the appropriate surface protective layer with a thickness ranging from a few micrometers (below 10-20 µm) to more than 30 µm and even several millimeters, many methodologies and technologies may be applied. Overall, coating processes can be divided into two categories: (i) wet coating approaches, which include electroplating, electroless plating, and hot-dip galvanizing methods, and (ii) dry coating approaches, which include brazing, weld overlays, physical vapor deposition (PVD), chemical vapor deposition (CVD), thermal spray techniques, and most recently cold spray technique 24 (Fig. 1d).
Antibiofilm protective coating. Biofilm is defined as a microbial community irreversibly attached to a surface and surrounded in self-producing extracellular polymeric substances (EPS). Mature biofilm formation on surfaces can results in a major loss in many industrial sectors include food industry, water systems and health care environments. In human, more than 80% of microbial infections cases including Enterobacteriaceae and Staphylococcaceae species are very challenging to treat when biofilms formed. Moreover, it has been reported that in comparison to planktonic bacterial cells mature biofilm can be 1000-fold more resistant to the antibiotic treatment which considered as major therapeutic challenges. Antibacterial surface coating materials derived from conventional organic compounds have historically been employed. Although such materials often include toxic components that are potentially risky for humans 25,26 , it may help to avoid both the spread of bacteria and the destruction of substances.
The widespread bacterial resistance to antibiotic treatments because of biofilm formation led to the need to develop an effective antibiofilm coated surfaces that can be safe to apply 27 . Developing an anti-adhesive surface, both physically or chemically, that inhibit bacteria cells from bond to it and building biofilms as a consequence of the adhesion is the first approach in the process 27 . Developing coatings that enable antimicrobial chemicals to be given in highly concentrated and tailored amounts precisely where they are needed is the second technique. Achieving this by the development of unique coating materials such as graphene/germanium 28 , black diamond 29 and ZnO-doped diamond-like carbon coatings 30 that are bacterial resistant, such technique can minimize the toxicity and resistance development occurring because of biofilm formation 31 . Furthermore, coating in which bactericidal chemicals are bonded to the surface in order to give long-term protection against bacterial contamination 32 , is becoming more popular. Although all three procedures are capable of imparting an antimicrobial effect on the coated surface, they each have their own set of limitations that should be taken into consideration when establishing a strategy for application. Present status of antimicrobial coating materials. Products that are currently on the market has been hindered by the fact that insufficient time has been devoted to the analysis and testing of the bioactive components that are contained in the protective coating [33][34][35] . Companies are making claims that their products would provide users with the ideal functional aspects; however, this has been a barrier to the success of the products that are currently on the market. Compounds derived from silver are used in the great majority of antimicrobial therapies that are now available to consumers. These goods have been developed to protect users against the potentially hazardous effects of microbes. The delayed antibacterial effect and associated toxicity of silver compounds have increased the amount of pressure placed on researchers to develop an alternative that is less hazardous 36,37 . The creation of a worldwide antimicrobial coating that is suitable for use both inside and outside is still proving to be a difficult task. This is due to the fact that there are associated dangers to both health and safety. Discovering an antibacterial agent that is less harmful to humans and finding out how to include it into a coating matrix that has a longer shelf life is a goal that is tremendously sought after 38 . The most recent antimicrobial and antibiofilm materials aim to kill bacteria either on direct contact or in close proximity after the release of the active agent. They can do so by either inhibiting the initial bacterial adhesion, which involves counteracting the formation of a protein layer on the surface, or by killing bacteria by disturbance of cell wall 35 . Cold spraying technique. Fundamentally, surface coating is the process of placing another layer to a component's surface in order to enhance surface-dependent qualities. The goal of surface coating is to customize the microstructure and/or composition of the near-surface area of the component 39 . The surface coating technology can be classified into different approached that are summarized in Fig. 2a. Coating may be subdivided into the categories of thermal, chemical, physical, and electrochemical, depending on the method that was used to create it.
Cold spray technique has many parallels to regular thermal spray methods. However, there are also major basic characteristics that make the cold spray process and cold-sprayed materials particularly distinctive. The cold spray technology is still in its infancy, but it shows a great deal of promise. In certain applications, the unique properties of cold spray provide substantial benefits, over-coming inherent limits of typical thermal spray method. It provides a means of overcoming significant constraints of conventional thermal spray technologies, in which the powders must be melt during the thermal spray technique in order to be deposited onto the substrate. Obviously, this traditional coating process is not suitable with the materials that are very sensitive to temperature, such as nanocrystalline, nanoparticles, amorphous, and metallic glasses [40][41][42] . Moreover, the as-thermal spray coating material are always show high levels of porosity and oxide. In contrast to the thermal  (Fig. 2b). In addition, the as-cold-spray coating material reveal high corrosion resistance, high strength and hardness, high conductivity, and high density 41 . Contrary to the advantages of cold spray coating process, there are still few disadvantages upon using this technique, as listed in Fig. 2b. When coating with pure ceramics powders such as Al 2 O 3 , TiO 2 , ZrO 2 , and WC, the cold spray method cannot be used. Ceramics/metal composite powders, on the other hand, may be used as feedstock materials for coatings. The same is true for the other approaches of thermal spraying; it is still difficult to spray complicated surfaces and the inside surfaces of pipes.
In light of the objective of the current work, which is to use metallic glassy powders as feedstock coating materials, it is obvious that traditional thermal spray cannot be used for such a purpose. This is due to the fact that the metallic glassy powders will crystallize upon the application of high temperatures 1 .
Aim of the present work. The bulk of the tools used in the medical and food sectors are made of austenitic stainless steel alloys (SUS316 and SUS304), which have a high chromium content ranging between 12 and 20 wt% and are utilized in the production of surgical instruments. It is understood that using chromium metal as an alloying element in steel alloys may greatly increase the corrosion resistance of a standard steel alloy, and this is commonly accepted. Stainless steel alloys, despite their high corrosion resistance, do not exhibit substantial antibacterial characteristics 38,39 . This is in contrast to their high corrosion resistance. Following this, it is possible to anticipate the development of infection and inflammation, which are mostly caused by the adhesion and colonization of bacteria on the surfaces of stainless steel biomaterials. With a significant difficulty linked with the bacterial adhesion and biofilm formation pathways, significant difficulties may arise, which may result in a deterioration in health, which may have a number of consequences that might directly or indirectly impact human health.
The present study is the Phase I of a project funded by the Kuwait Foundation for the Advancement of Sciences (KFAS), under Contract number: 2010-550401 to investigate the feasibility of using MA technique for production of metallic glassy Cu-Zr-Ni ternary powders (Table 1), for the purpose of producing antibiofilm/ SUS304 surface protective coating. The Phase II of the project, which will be started on January 2023, will examine in detail the electrochemical corrosion characteristics and mechanical behavior of this system. Detailed microbiological testing of different bacterial species will be conducted.
In the present paper, the influence of the Zr alloying element content on the glass forming ability (GFA) is discussed based on morphological, and structural characteristics. Aside from that, the antibacterial properties of coated metallic glassy powders coated/SUS304 composite is explored. In addition, the present work has been carried out to investigate the possibility of structural transformations of metallic glassy powders occurring during the cold spray process within the supercooled liquid region of the fabricated metallic glassy system.

Results and discussion
Morphology. In this section, the morphological changes that were taken place upon low-energy ball milling of elemental Cu, Zr, and Ni powders are presented. As illustrative instances, two different systems composed of Cu 50 Zr 20 Ni 30 , and Cu 50 Zr 40 Ni 10 will be used as reprehensive examples. The MA process may be divided into three distinct stages, as indicated by the metallographic characteristics of the powders produced during the milling stages (Fig. 3). During the ball milling process, the amount of effective kinetic energy that could be delivered to the metal powders was affected by a combination of parameters, as illustrated in Fig. 1a. This includes collision between both the balls and the powders, pressure clipping of powders stuck between milling media or between the milling media and the, impact of the falling balls, shear and abrasion caused by dragging of powders between moving ball milling media, and shock wave transmitted through crop load by falling balls (Fig. 1a). As a result of cold-welding taking place during the early stage of MA (3 h), elemental Cu, Zr, and Ni powders were heavily deformed to produce large powder particles (larger than 1 mm in diameter). These large composite particles are characterized by formation of thick lamella of the alloying elements (Cu, Zr, Ni), as presented in Fig. 3a,b. Increasing the MA time to 12 h (intermediate stage), led to increase the kinetic energy of the ball mill, leading to disintegrate the composite powders into finer powders (less than 200 µm), as shown in Fig. 3c,d. At this stage, the applied shear forces lead to the formation of fresh-metallic surfaces, having fine intimated layers of Cu, Zr, Table 1. Elemental analysis conducted by field-emission scanning electron microscope (FE-SEM)/energy dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDS) of the starting materials for as-hand mixed Cu 50 Zr 40 Ni 10 , Cu 50 Zr 30 Ni 20 , Cu 50 Zr 20 Ni 30 , and Cu 50 Zr 10 Ni 40 powders. All of the metallic glassy Cu 50 (Zr 50−x Ni x ) alloys listed in Table were prepared by mechanical alloying (MA) method with the use of a low-energy ball mill (Fig. 1a).    Fig. 3c,d. As a result of layer refining, a solid-stage reaction was taken place at the interfaces of the lamella to produce a new phase. At the culmination of the MA process (after 50 h), the lamella-like metallography was just faintly visible ( Fig. 3e,f), but the polished surface of the powders displayed mirror-like metallography. This signifies that the MA process has been completed and the production of a single reacting phase has taken place. The elemental composition of the zones indexed in Fig. 3e (I, II, III),f was determined by using the field-emission scanning electron microscope (FE-SEM) in conjunction with energy dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDS) (IV, V, VI).
In Table 2, the elemental concentration of the alloying elements is shown as a percentage of the total weight for each of the zones that were chosen in Fig. 3e,f. When these results are compared to those of the starting nominal composition for Cu 50 Zr 20 Ni 30 and Cu 50 Zr 40 Ni 10 , which are listed in Table 1, it is possible to realize that the composition of these two end products had values that were extremely similar to the nominal composition. Additionally, the associated composition values for the zones listed in Fig. 3e,f did not refer to a significant deterioration or fluctuation in composition from one zone to another for each sample. This is evidenced by the fact that there is no change in composition from one zone to another. This points to the production of homogenous alloy powders, as shown in Table 2.
FE-SEM micrographs for the end-product Cu 50 (Zr 50−x Ni x ) powders, obtained after 50 of MA time, is presented in Fig. 4a-d for x equals 10, 20, 30 and 40 at.%, respectively. Following this step of milling, the powders were aggregated due to the van der Walls effect, which, resulted in the formation of large aggregates consisting of ultrafine particles with diameters ranging from 73 to 126 nm, as seen in Fig. 4.
Before the powders were charged into the cold spray feeder, they were first sonicated for fifteen minutes in ethanol of analytical grade, and then they were dried at a temperature of 150 °C for two hours. This step had to be taken in order to successfully combat the agglomeration that often caused a number of significant issues throughout the coating process 1 . After the completion of the MA process, further characterizations were carried out in order to investigate into the degree to which the alloy powders were homogenous. Figure 5a-d, respectively, illustrate the FE-SEM micrograph as well as the corresponding EDS maps for the alloying elements of Cu, Zr, and Ni of Cu 50 Zr 30 Ni 20 alloy obtained after 50 h of M time. To point out the obvious, the alloy powders that were produced after this step were uniform since they did not reveal any compositional fluctuations that went beyond the sub-nano level, as shown in  Fig. 7a,c, respectively. According to the bright field image (BFI) of the powders that were produced after 6 h of MA, the powders comprised of large grains with sharp boundaries of elemental fcc-Cu, hcp-Zr, and fcc-Ni, and there was no indication that a reacted phase had formed, as shown in Fig. 7a. Additionally, the related selected area diffraction pattern (SADP) taken from the middle zone of (a) revealed sharp-spot diffraction patters (Fig. 7b) indicating the existence of large crystallites and the absence of a reacted phase.
As can be seen in Fig. 7c, extending the MA duration to 18 h led to the development of severe lattice defects that were coupled with plastic deformation. During this intermediate stage of the MA process, the powders experienced from a variety of defects, including stacking faults, lattice defects, and point defects (Fig. 7). These defects led the large grains to split apart along their grain boundaries into subgrains that were less than 20 nm in size (Fig. 7c).
The local structure of the Cu 50 Z 30 Ni 20 powders that were milled for 36 h of MA time, possessed the formation of ultrafine nano grains embedded into a noncrystalline fine matrix, as shown in Fig. 8a. The local EDS analysis indicate that those nanocrystalline clusters shown in Fig. 8a were related to unprocessed alloying elements of Cu, www.nature.com/scientificreports/ Zr, and Ni powders. Meanwhile, the Cu content of the matrix fluctuated from ~ 32 at.% (poor region) to ~ 74 at.% (rich region), suggested the formation of heterogeneous product. Furthermore, the corresponding SADP of the powders obtained after this stage of milling, revealed halo diffuse primary and secondary rings of an amorphous phase, overlapped with sharp spots related to those unprocessed alloying elements, as displayed in Fig. 8b. Toward the end of MA process (50 h), Cu 50 (Zr 50−x Ni x ), X; 10, 20, 30, and 40 at.% powders without any exceptions possessed maze-like morphology of amorphous phase, as displayed in Fig. 9a-d. In the corresponding SADP of each composition, neither spot-like diffraction nor sharp ring patterns can be detected. This indicates that unprocessed crystalline metals are not present, and instead, noncrystalline alloy powders have formed. These related SADPs that displayed halo diffuse patterns were also utilized as evidence of the development of an amorphous phase in the materials of the end-product.  Fig. 10a,b,e, respectively. Whereas the DSC trace for amorphous Cu 50 Zr 20 Ni 30 is displayed individually in Fig. 10c. Meanwhile, of Cu 50 Zr 30 Ni 20 sample that was heated in the DSC up to ~ 700 °C is shown in Fig. 10d.
As can be seen in Fig. 10, the DSC curves for all composition with different Ni concentrations (x) indicated two distinct occurrences, one endothermic and the other exothermic, respectively. The first events that are www.nature.com/scientificreports/ endothermic correspond to T g , whereas the second occurrences are correlated to T x . The region of span that existed horizontally between The horizontal span existed between T g and T x is referred to as the supercooled liquid region (ΔT x = T x -T g ). The results have indicated that T g , and T x for Cu 50 Zr 40 Ni 10 sample (Fig. 10a) that are laid at 526 °C, and 612 °C, respectively shifted to the low temperature side of 482 °C, and 563 °C upon increasing the Ni content (x) to 20 at.%, as displayed in Fig. 10b. Accordingly, the ΔT x for Cu 50 Zr 40 Ni 10 was decreased from 86 °C (Fig. 10a) to 81 °C for Cu 50 Zr 30 Ni 20 (Fig. 10b). Decreasing the values of T g , T x , and ΔT x to the level of 447 °C, 526 °C, and 79 °C was also observed for MG Cu 50 Zr 40 Ni 10 alloy (Fig. 10b). This suggests that an increase in the Ni content led to a reduction in the thermal stability of the MG alloy. In contrast, MG Cu 50 Zr 20 Ni 30 alloy exhibited a lower value of T g (507 °C) in comparison to MG Cu 50 Zr 40 Ni 10 alloy; nonetheless, its T x showed a value that was comparable to the former (612 °C). As a consequence of this, ΔT x exhibited a higher value (87 °C), as can be seen in Fig. 10c. MG Cu 50 (Zr 50−x Ni x ) systems, exemplified by MG Cu 50 Zr 20 Ni 30 alloy crystallized into crystalline phases of fcc-ZrCu 5 , orthorhombic-Zr 7 Cu 10 , and orthorhombic-ZrNi, through a single sharp exothermic peak (Fig. 10c). This noncrystalline to crystalline phase transformation was confirmed by the XRD (Fig. 10d) of the MG-sample that was heated in a DSC up to 700 °C.
Cold spray coating. Figure 11 displays a photo taken during the cold spray coating process that was carried out in the present work. In this study, the as-synthesized metallic glassy powder particles (taking Cu 50 Zr 20 Ni 30 , as a typical example), obtained after 50 h of MA time, were used as antibacterial feedstock materials for coating stainless steel sheets (SUS304) using a cold spraying technique. The cold spray approach was selected for the purpose of coating among the thermal spray family of techniques because it is the most effective approach in the thermal spray family, in which it can be used in coating of metallic metastable temperature sensitive material (such as amorphous and nanocrystalline phases) powders without obeying to phase transformations. This was the primary factor in the selection of this method. The cold spray process is taking place by utilizing highvelocity particles, which, upon impact with a substrate or previously deposited particles, convert the particle's kinetic energy into plastic deformation, strain, and heat 42 .
It is necessary for the kinetic energy of a particle as well as the momentum of each particle in the coating formation to be converted into other forms of energy through mechanisms such as plastic deformation (both substrate and particle interactions for the initial particles and particle-particle interactions as the coating formation builds), void consolidation, particle-particle rotation, strain, and ultimately heat 39 . Furthermore, if not all of the incoming kinetic energy is converted into heat and strain energy, the outcome is an elastic collision,  www.nature.com/scientificreports/ which means that the particle will simply rebound after the impact. It has been pointed out that 90% of the applied impact energy on the particle/substrate materials is converted into local heat 40 . Additionally, when the impact stresses are applied, high plastic strain rates are achieved in the contact particle/substrate zone within a very short time 41,42 . Plastic deformation is often thought of as a process for the dissipation of energy, or more specifically, as a source of heat in the interfacial area. However, the temperature increase in the interfacial region is typically not sufficient to produce interfacial melting or to significantly promote atomic interdiffusion. There are no publications that the authors are aware of that investigate the influence of the features of these metallic glassy powders on the bonding and deposition of powders that occur when cold spray method is used.
The BFI of MG Cu 50 Zr 20 Ni 30 alloy powders can be seen in Fig. 12a, which was coated on a SUS 304 substrate (Figs. 11, 12b). It can be seen in the image that the coating powders have maintained their original amorphous structure since they have a delicate maze structure without any crystalline features or lattice defects. The image,  www.nature.com/scientificreports/ on the other hand, suggested the presence of foreign phase(s), which was hinted by the nanoparticles that were incorporated into the matrix of the MG coating powders (Fig. 12a). Figure 12c depicts the indexed nanobeam diffraction pattern (NBDP) that is associated with zone I (Fig. 12a). As can be seen in Fig. 12c, the NBDP exhibited a weak halo diffuse pattern of an amorphous structure coexisted with sharp patches that corresponded to crystalline big-cube Zr 2 Ni metastable-plus tetragonal-CuO phases. When traveling from the nozzle of the gun under supersonic flow toward the SUS 304 in an open air, the formation of CuO may be attributed to oxidation  An independent experiment was conducted in order to verify this potential mechanism for the formation of big cube Zr 2 Ni nanoparticles. During this experiment, the powders were sprayed from the gun in the direction of the SUS 304 substrate at 550 °C; however, they were removed from the SUS304 strip as soon as possible (~ 60 s) in order to illuminate the annealing effect on the powders. Another set of experiments was carried out, and in this trial, the powders were removed from the substrate after deposition for ~ 180 s. Figure 13a,b show the dark field images (DFIs) obtained by a scanning transmission electron microscope (STEM) for the two sprayed materials that were deposited on a SUS 304 substrate for 60 and 180 s, respectively. The image of the powders deposited for 60 s had no morphological details and revealed featureless (Fig. 13a). This is also was confirmed by the XRD, which indicated that the general structure of these powders is amorphous, as suggested by the broad primary and secondary diffraction maxima displayed in Fig. 14a. These indicate the absence of precipitation of metastable/intermediate phase, where the powders maintain their original amorphous structure. In contrast, the powders sprayed at the same temperature (550 °C), but left on the substrate material for 180 s have shown precipitation of nanodimensional crystalline grain, as indexed by the arrows shown in Fig. 13b. Figure 13c,d, respectively, depict the FE-HRTEM image and corresponding NBDP of zone I that is shown in Fig. 12a. During the cold spray procedure, which was repeated five times at 550 °C for 1800s, a significant volume fraction of nanocrystalline spherical grains were obtained, and these grains tended to be embedded into the metallic glassy matrix, as shown in Fig. 13c. This is indicated by the atomic resolution TEM image that was obtained. As suggested by the indexed NBDP, the NBDP was able to validate that these nano-spheres were connected to the big-cube form of Zr 2 Ni 43 (Fig. 13d).
The analysis of the diffracted lines presented in Fig. 14b reveals that the deposited powders for 180 s are connected to Ti 2 Ni-structure 43 (E9 3 structure, space group Fd3m). The lattice constant, a 0 , of this crystalline phase was determined to be 1.2295 nm by using the principal diffracted line (3 3 3) in Fig. 14b. Figure 14c shows the DSC curves of the powders after they were sprayed five times at 550 °C for 1800s. By comparing the scan of this sample with that of powders acquired after 50 h of MA time during which the crystallization process was carried out in a single step, we were able to determine that there was a significant difference between the two samples (Fig. 10c). It has come to attention that there has been a significant shift in the way crystallization operates as a result of the cold spray technique. This is implied by the change in the crystallization process, which takes place through two steps, as characterized by the two exothermic reactions that appeared at 591 °C and 634 °C, respectively, as shown in Fig. 14c. The crystallization processes, which was taken place through two steps has led to the formation of orthorhombic-phases of ZrNi, and Zr 7 Cu 10 , as evidenced by the XRD displayed in Fig. 14d,e, respectively.
The typical MG-Cu 50 Zr 30 Ni 20 coated/SUS304 sample, which was vertically mounted on Cu-SEM sample holder, is displayed in Fig. 15a. The FE-SEM image of the plan view of this sample is shown in Fig. 15b. As can be seen in Fig. 15b, the sample, which has a thickness of less than 22 µm, exhibited features of dense structure and a surface morphology that was relatively rough. It can be realized the absence of micro cracks at the interface between the coating-and substrate-materials, implying the formation of well bonded composite, as shown in Fig. 15b.  Fig. 15c. This low magnification STEM image has indicated a good bonding beyond the nano level between the coating MG-Cu 50 Zr 30 Ni 20 material and SUS304 substrate, as characterized by the absence of pores and cracks at the interface (Fig. 15c). The FE-HRTEM of regions I, and II indexed in Fig. 15c are shown in Fig. 15d,g, respectively. The corresponding image of zone I revealed noncrystalline structure with maze-like morphology, indicating the presence of an amorphous phase (Fig. 15d). Moreover, the NBDP (Fig. 15e) related to the image displayed in Fig. 15c revealed halo pattern of an amorphous structure. The FE-HRTEM image and corresponding NBDP related to zone II, which is located at the substrate material (SUS 304) are displayed in Fig. 15f,g, respectively. The sample, which revealed continuous staking faults displayed fringe-images related to austenitic SUS304 of zone axis < 110 > , as shown in Fig. 15f,g. Figure 16a shows the bulk density of MG-Cu 50 (Zr 50−x Ni x ) 50 , where x equals to 10, 20, 30, and 40 at.% coated SUS304. The density measurements were conducted at ambient temperature with pure toluene, using Archimedes' approach. For the purpose of this investigation, the sheet of SUS304 substrate (Fig. 16b), which was coated with ~ 25 µm thickness MG-powders was divided into equals coupons of (1 cm × 1 cm), as displayed in Fig. 16c. The weight of each sample with different Ni concentrations, and their dimensions were measured preciously, to calculate the volume of the samples. This procedure were repeated three times, using three different samples. The density of pure SUS304 (before coating) was measured and found to be 7.93 g/cm 3 (Fig. 16a). The density of the composite sample contains 40 at.% Zr was 8.56 g/cm 3 (Fig. 16a). Increasing the Zr content to 20 at.% and 30 at.% led to a significant decrease in the density to be 8.46 and 8.06 g/cm 3 respectively, as shown in Fig. 16a. MG-Cu 50 Zr 10 Ni 40 coated/SUS304 had a bulk density of 8.03 g/cm 3 .  Fig. 17. Figure 17a shows the inhibitory effect of cold spray coated SUS304 substrate with elemental Cu, Ni, and Zr metals. In the meanwhile, the antibacterial behavior of cold spray coated SUS304 binary (Zr 50 Fig. 17b. Although it was reported that the    (Fig. 17b) by at least one log at all times in comparison to SUS304, Ni and Zr control alone (Fig. 17a). These results were statistically significant (p < 0.05, n = 3). It well known that mature biofilm cells are more resistant to treatment with antimicrobial reagents than planktonic cells, classic treatment with antibiotic are usually not sufficiently to reduce biofilms formed on implant devises and the replacement of the implant is the only way so solve the problem [44][45][46][47] . Many studies demonstrated the antibiofilm inhibitory effect of Zr, Cu and Ni on coated surfaces. It has been reported that coated stainless steel with 304-Cu, 420-Cu and 317L-Cu metallic alloys showed strong antibacterial effect against biofilm formation due to a continuous release of Cu ions into the environment 48,49 . Moreover, the antibiofilm inhibitory effect of Zr has been reported by Al-Radha et al. who reported that pure zirconia showed significant effect against biofilm smooth surfaces 50 . Manicone et al. 51 , demonstrated that use of ZrO 2 surfaces can significantly inhibit the    53,54 .
The antibiofilm mode of action of Cu and the effect of releasing of Cu 2+ has been widely reported [48][49][50] . The release of Cu 2+ ions from metallic surfaces and the direct contact with bacterial cells are the main reasons for the Cu to be effective. Moreover, antimicrobial effect of Cu includes bacterial cell injuries, outer and inner cell membrane damage, oxidative damage due to production of reactive oxygen species (ROS), inhibition of enzyme production and nucleic acid degradation has been reported 49 .
It has been demonstrated that the combination of Cu, Zr and Ni can reduce the bacteria attachment up to 99% 53 . However, most studies showed the inhibition of biofilm formation after coating the surfaces with more than 90% Cu (Table 3), in this study we can achieve significant inhibition with only 50% Cu content. Our present results supports and suggest that Cu 50 Zr 20 Ni 30 , Cu 50 Zr 30 Ni 20 and Cu 50 Zr 40 Ni 10 coated materials (Fig. 17b) will be very effective against biofilm formation. Nevertheless, the only drawback of our present study is that one species of bacteria has been used as a model, which may not reflect in vivo environments, multi biofilm forming bacteria need to be investigated.

Conclusions
Based on the present study, ternary Cu 50 (Zr 50−x Ni x ) metallic glassy systems (x; 10, 20, 30, and 40 at.%) were synthesized from elemental powders, using low energy ball milling technique. The end-product obtained after 50 h revealed high thermal stability, as indexed by high T g (447-526 °C), and T x (526-612 °C), with large ΔT x . For the purpose of the present work, cold spray coating approach was used to fabricate Cu 50 (Zr 50−x Ni x ) metallic glassy coated/SUS 304 sheets at temperature being just above the T g . Due to the heat generated during plastic deformation of SUS 304 substrate taken place during cold spraying process, significant volume fractions of metallic glassy coating powders devitrificated into a big cube Zr 2 Ni metastable phase. According to the results produced in this study, ternary systems (CuZrNi) were the most effective coating metals for inhibition of E. coli bacterial cell adhesion in comparison to other systems investigated. Moreover, CuZrNi systems showed prolonged antibiofilm effect up to 72 h. Although CuZrNi metallic alloys demonstrate the best antibiofilm inhibitory effect against the model E. coli species, it should not consider as the only problem solver of biofilm formed on surfaces. It has been reported that bacterial strains can develop a resistance pathways to metals similar to resistance developed to antibiotic treatments. Thus, overcome resistance of biofilm to metal should be further studied.

Materials and methods. Preparations of Cu-based metallic glassy alloy powders by mechanical alloy-
ing. Powders of pure metallic alloying elements such as Cu, Ti, Zr, Nb, and Ni (with purity more than 99.9 wt% and diameter less than 20 µm) were employed as starting reactant. The powders of the system listed in Table 1 were balanced to give the average nominal composition of the starting charge for Cu-based binary, ternary and multicomponent system (Table 1), and then mixed in a glove box (UNILAB Pro Glove Box Workstation, mBRAUN, Germany) filled with helium gas to obtain the desired composition. Then after, a certain quantity (150 g) of the powders for the desired system were charged into an Cr-steel vial (1000 ml in capacity) and sealed along with 100 Cr-steel balls (14 mm in diameter). The weight ratio of the balls-to-powder was 36:1. The MA process was started by mounting the vial on a roller mill (RM20) provided by Zoz GmbH, Germany, operated at room temperature with a rotation speed of 235 rpm. The progress of the solid-state reaction was monitored by www.nature.com/scientificreports/ interrupting the MA process after selected ball milling time, where the vial was opened in the glove box to take a represented sample. All samples were then characterized by different analysis.
Fabrication of Cu-based metallic glassy powders coated/SUS304 composites by cold spray process. In recognition of the way that the powders were noncrystalline (amorphous) when they were first synthesized, it was anticipated that they would crystallize into a stable (crystalline) phase when heated above their crystallization temperature. Given that the goal of this research is to determine if metallic glassy Cu-based metallic glassy alloy powders impact the growth of biofilms, it is critical that the glassy phase be maintained throughout the spraying process. A cold spraying procedure was used to cover both sides of SUS304 sheets as a result of this. As a substrate metal, stainless steel (SUS304) sheets were utilized, which were first cleaned with acetone and ethanol and then dried in an oven at 150 °C for 1 h. Before the coating process began, the surface of the substrate was prepared with alumina blasting at ambient temperature. It is important to note that, unlike thermal spray combustion-based approaches, the cold spray approach is accomplished at low temperatures (in the range of 100-900 °C), which is far lower than the melting points of the feedstock powders. In the present work, the cold spraying process was initiated at a low temperature (400 °C) with a supersonic jet processed at a very high velocity (1200 m/s).

Materials characterizations.
General structure. Using equipment from RIGAKU-SMARTLAB 9 kW, X-ray diffraction was used to evaluate the general structural changes that occurred as a result of ball milling Cu-based master alloys. Using CuKα radiation with a wavelength of 0.15418 nm and an operating voltage of 45 kV 200 mA, all of the samples were evaluated at a speed of 2θ/min through a continuous 2/θ scan mode. The detector utilized was a high-speed 1D X-ray detector called D/teX Ultra 1D mode (D/teX) with Ni Filter. The diffraction patterns were acquired across a range of 20° to 80° in 2θ, with a step size of 0.02/2 and a duration of 1 s/step for each stage in the process. The XRD was produced as a consequence of constructive and destructive interference brought about by the scattering of X-rays from atoms arranged in a regular array. Diffraction lines appeared at angles that were consistent with Bragg's method.
Using JEOL microscopes of the JEOL 2000F model with a resolution of 0.17 nm and operating at a voltage of 200 kV, a field emission high-resolution transmission electron microscope (FE-HRTEM) that was equipped with energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDS) was used to examine powder samples of as-synthesized materials. After dissolving the sample powders in ethanol, a few drops of the resulting solution were placed on a copper (Cu)-microgrid and allowed to dry in a vacuum. After that, the microgid was installed onto the TEM transfer rod before being transferred to the vacuum sample chamber of the TEM. EDS was utilized to do elemental analysis on the micrographs that were acquired for the bright field image (BFI), dark field image (DFI), and selected area electron diffraction patterns (SADPs). Details of these measurements but for a different system are described elsewhere 44 . Thermal stabilities. Shimadzu Thermal Analysis System/TA-60WS, using differential scanning calorimeter (DSC) was employed to investigate the thermal stability of the as-ball milled powders, indexed by the transition glass temperature (T g ), and crystallization temperature (T x ), using a heating rate of 40 °C/min.
Bacterial strain and biofilm growth conditions. Escherichia coli (ATCC 25922) was used as a test organism. Biofilms were grown according to our previous work 25 . Sterile monocoated systems (Cu, Zr, Ni), binary systems (ZrNi, CuZr) and ternary systems (CuZrNi) triplicate coupons (22-mm 2 ) were positioned vertically in 50-ml conical tubes with 6 ml pre-warmed BHI (Brain Heart Infusion). 100 μl 0.5 McFarland standard suspensions (equivalent to 1.5 × 108 CFU ml −1 ) of a 24 h culture Planktonic cells were added to each tube. Bacterial inoculum preparations, overnight bacterial culture was centrifuge (8000g, 10 min) to produce cell pellet, bacterial cells were then washed with deionized water followed by resuspension in BHI and optical density was set to 108 CFU/ ml. Tubes was then incubated on a shaker to allow biofilm to form. Triplicate coated coupons was removed at each time point (24, 48, 72 h) and then rinsed with phosphate buffer solution (PBS) to remove non-adherent bacterial cells. Coated coupons were then transfer to fresh tube with 6 ml BHI and vortex for 1 min at maximum speed. For viable count, suspension result after vortexing were then serially diluted in PBS and plated on nutrient agar (NA) viable bacteria were then enumerated.

Data availability
The datasets used and/or analysed during the current study available from the corresponding author on reasonable request.